Ask Dr. Warren ~ The Questions & Their Answers


20 December 1999

  1. No Toys for William This Christmas
  2. Heat or Ice
  3. Hemoglobin Barts
  4. Normal X-Ray, Severe Leg Pain
  5. Lungs
  6. Hyper Baby
  7. Sleepy Newborn
  8. Excess Infant Weight Gain
  9. Disclaimer

Disclaimer

Dear Readers:
Dr. Warren hopes to help all who ask his advice and to enlighten all who read Ask Dr. Warren. For your own well being please keep in mind that advice you read here may not apply exactly to your own situation, and that if you are sick, no information on the web can take the place of a hands on examination by your physician who knows you and cares about you.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Dear Readers:
This question originally appeared in Ask Dr. Warren on 22 December 1997. Because of the seasonal nature of the question and the message conveyed in the answer, I thought it was worth repeating.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

No Toys for William This Christmas

Dear Dr. Warren: What can the repercussions be or maybe psychological and emotional effects is a better choice, be on a three year old boy, when he is in a room full of people, relatives, friends, holding his magazine page of toys he wants for Christmas, and his mother, who is upset about something and acting extremely haughty, says in a loud voice to the boy's Grandfather "No toys for William this Christmas. Don't get him anything. He has too many toys and has to learn to appreciate what he has." He starts to cry and tries to show his pictures of toys to his Great Grandmother and Aunt, but his mother says again "No toys for William this Christmas." Everyone in that room could not believe what they heard. Please, Dr. Warren, I need to know if this child will feel worthless? She also said Santa Claus would not come because William had too many toys. We know she and her husband bought them throughout the year, little cars from the supermarket. She is punishing him for his toys she bought! Please, I cannot stop thinking about this little child, being denied the anticipation of Santa coming, and giving one of his drawings to his great grandmother, of sharing, and receiving. I cannot believe a 3 year old can learn to appreciate what he has in a few days. This is so serious to me, I am writing you now, at 3:54 in the AM. I can't sleep thinking about him. I am his grandmother, my son is his father. Today is my son's birthday, and I am so bewildered and heartsick he is accepting this.

I will appreciate and look forward to your reply. Thank you.

-Grandma

Dear Grandma: I can understand your distress, but you must remember that you are not privy to all the details of why William's mother feels he needs to be disciplined this way. I would hope that his mother will not ruin Christmas since it is such a magic time of year for children. But keep in mind that the threat of no gifts for children who misbehave has always been part of the Christmas mystique. Children have been told through the ages that Santa is watching to see if they are "naughty or nice" and that bad children get a lump of coal in their stockings instead of a gift. The risk is to not state the threat so strongly that a parent has no choice but to follow through or lose credibility. Unless a child is truly able to understand and misbehaves badly in spite of his understanding, it is best for a child not to pay such a high price as missing a rare and special event. Punishments can always be meted out in another way on another day as long as the child is aware that his reprieve is only the result of the special occasion and punishments will not be routinely postponed.

Mom may still make the best of this situation by telling William what he must do to make amends, and then in the spirit of charity and teaching her child how to behave, she should accept his efforts even if they are less than perfect. And while we're talking about charity, if Mom thinks William has too much and doesn't appreciate what he has, why not help him participate in the joy of giving by visiting a shelter or poor community and giving some gifts to those who have less.

As to the effect this will have on William, a lot more depends on how William's mother treats him all year than what happens on Christmas. Children are resilient, and William will get over this before you do. The loss of one Christmas will not damage him and there will be other Christmases. On the other hand, if William's mother is emotionally abusive to him, he will carry scars for the rest of his life that even wonderful Christmases will never erase. Children are our future. They are truly God's most precious gift. They need discipline in the form of a strong but gentle guiding hand that is nurturing and loving.

Happy Holidays!

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Heat or Ice

Dear Dr. Warren: Recently my temper got out of control again and I kicked the side of an elevator with my left foot (I'm a righty). The pain was sharp but I didn't really need to limp for about 15 minutes. Then the pain started setting in when I started walking. This is when I noticed that my big toe had begun to swell. I also noticed that it started to swell underneath the toe, under the joint. I went about the whole day without applying anything until I got home 9 hours later. When I took off my socks, I noticed a discoloration of black an blue and purple right below the nail. I took my friends' advice and put my foot in hot/warm water with salt. This is day two and the swelling and pain has gone down a little. My question is: Was it and is it better now to use hot/warm water or just ice? I always thought it was ice but I always listen to my friends. Thanks.

-Leo

Dear Leo: Use ice on an acute injury or for treating chronic injury or inflammation to decrease blood flow to the area and decrease swelling. Use heat to increase blood flow to an area and speed healing when an injury is no longer inflamed or when there is infection.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Hemoglobin Barts

Dear Dr. Warren: I am new to the internet and would like to ask you a question. I have a 15 month boy and what I'm going to tell you has been worrying me. When he was born, the PKU test done at the hospital showed the presence of "Barts Hemoglobin" , which from what I have been explained, is a form of anemia or Thalassemia. He was retested at his Pediatricians office and the first test done came back stating there wasn't enough blood drawn to do the test and the 2nd test came up with the same result as the hospitals test. His pediatrician doesn't seem worried and told me I could have him tested more. He feels it could have been present at birth and will go away. He also stated that my son has a trait Thalassemia and the only time I have to worry, is when he gets married and wants to have children. Dr. please help! I do not know who to contact for information. If this is the case, I would like my husband and I to get tested. We don't even know how he could of inherited this trait. I know it's common in the Mediterranean, but my husbands family and mine are Cuban and some, on both sides, from Spain. Please help. Thank you very much!

-C

Dear C: Hemoglobin Barts is a hemoglobin consisting of all gamma chains. Normal A hemoglobin is made of alpha and beta chains. Gamma chain production generally ceases between 3 and 6 months so that the Hemoglobin Barts may disappear. Hemoglobin Barts usually occurs when there is decreased alpha or beta chain production which is what Thalassemia is. At 15 months of age, if your son has no findings suggestive of Thalassemia, he most likely has the trait rather than the disease, in which case your doctor is correct in stating that the main concern would be if he marries someone who also carries a trait for a genetic anemia. Thalassemia trait is inherited, although it could occur as a new mutation. You and your husband could be tested to see if either of you carries the trait, but what is more important is for your son to be tested so that you know exactly what he has and your mind can be put at ease. Since the trait doesn't cause any significant symptoms except a mild anemia, it is not surprising that you and your husband are not aware of any family history of the disease. You may have to delve quite deep to find relatives who have knowledge of it.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Normal X-Ray, Severe Leg Pain

Dear Dr. Warren: Our 5 year old son had a playmate fall on his leg (mid thigh ) yesterday. He complained very little yesterday, but as the night went on we noticed a limp. No swelling. This morning, he could not stand on the leg, or even move the leg without crying. We carried him to our pediatrician and he told us he feared a fracture and sent us to the hospital for x-rays. The x-rays showed no fractures and we were told to give him rest and Advil. However, we are concerned that something might have been missed. The acute pain he has upon moving the leg seems very sharp, even when I carry him any side movement to the thigh will cause him to scream. He absolutley cannot put any weight on the leg. There seems to be no real tenderness, just pain caused by movement or weight. His willingness to stay immobile is very much out of character for this 5 year old. Should we give a certain amount of time before we request more attention? This kid does not usually complain about any type of aches or pains, so he's pretty believable when he says his "weg" hurts.

Thank you.

-L

Dear L: If your son is complaining of severe pain he should be evaluated by an orthopedist. X-rays do not pick up all injuries. A soft tissue injury or an inflammation of a joint after injury may not show up on x-ray. A hairline fracture or a fracture through a growth plate may also be difficult to find on the initial x-ray.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Lungs

Hi Dr. Warren: My name is Brenna and I am in the 3rd Grade. I am doing a Science Fair Project on Lung Power. I am looking for information on lungs and vital capacity any questions you can answer for me would be great or any web site that you could recommend for me to look at.
    Questions:
  1. What is vital capacity and why is it important?
  2. What is reserve air capacity and why is it important?
  3. What are good things for your lungs?
  4. What are bad things for your lungs?
  5. What can or should an elementry age child do to improve their vital capacity?
  6. What can or should a middle school and high school age child do to improve their vital capacity?
  7. What can or should an adult do to improve their vital capacity?
  8. What can or should an eldery person do to improve their vital capacity?
  9. How can we all keep our lungs healthy?
  10. What are some of the most common diseases that affect our lung capacity?
    (if possible could you name some for each of the 4 age groups I mentioned above?)
Thank you!

Sincerely,
Brenna :)

Dear Brenna:

Check the National Jewish Medical and Research Center Web site for information about many subjects related to lung disease.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Hyper Baby

Dear Dr. Warren: I have an 18 m.o. son who until now has been a loving, happy, easy going child. He has been in daycare for 4 months and just last week he has started becoming aggressive and extremely hyper. It is hard for me to decide if he is happy or what. First example, I picked him up early at daycare 3:00 for an ENT apt. We went to the big Dr's office and he started running the perimeter of the waiting room and yelling "aaagh!" The other children were in the corner play area and quite honestly he was scaring some of them - being so loud. I brought him in front of me and told him quietly that he needed to behave. I don't like to disipline in public. He would not sit still or be quiet. He was being a pest.

Second example, he has begun to go crazy in the tub. He has always loved bath time and we encourage fun in the tub. He now splashes water everywhere, jumps around, swims from one end to another, and gets the entire bathroom soaking wet. We have had to limit the amount of water in the tub. And overall he has become a dare devil in every situation. Is this normal for this age or am I being overly concerned? He will not respond to time out. He immediately gets up from where I put him and if I put him in his room he screams bloody murder and trys to get out. It settles nothing.

Please advise.

-Allison

Dear Allison: Children change so much during the first few years of life that it's sometimes difficult to be sure what is a natural development and what is a response to stress or external stimulation. Personalities vary considerably from child to child. It is safe to say that not all 18 month olds exhibit aggressive or wild behavior, but many do. Sometimes learning what's acceptable behavior requires being disciplined for unacceptable behavior. As a result, some children who were never a problem to control sometimes become unexpectedly difficult since their previous good nature was a case of good fortune rather than learned behavior.

If your child's behavior represents a sudden departure from his previous behavior, a discussion with his daycare provider is in order. Perhaps he has learned to be aggressive in response to or from another child. If nothing has changed in daycare, a look at the home situation is in order to see if any stresses may be affecting his behavior. Young children may often have no clue what's going on in the adult world around them, but they can certainly sense when something is wrong.

Time out is an effective means of disciplining even young children, but it must be enforced consistently and be kept long enough to make an impression, yet short enough to match the understanding and attention span of the child. It also shouldn't be the first resort. Redirecting a child's behavior through distraction, gentle guidance, and substitution of alternative behaviors should be the first approach. For more information read my article, Managing the Difficult Child: Toddlers.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Sleepy Newborn

Dear Dr. Warren: My son is three weeks old. He has a doctor's appointment next week but I'm worried because he sleeps so much. Everyone tells me I'm crazy to worry and I should thank God for such a good baby. He only cries when I change him. He's just really good. He has normal bowel movements and has gained 2 lbs. 4 oz. He nurses well. Should I be worried?

-DA

Dear DA: Normal newborns sleep as little as 12 hours a day and as much as 22 hours each day. If your son is nursing well and gaining well then there is no need to worry.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Excess Infant Weight Gain

Dear Dr. Warren: At my newborn son's one-month visit he weighed 11 pounds (he weighed 7lbs., 3ozs. at birth). The doctor seemed appalled that he weighed this much and basically made us feel like terrible parents! My son does not have rolls of fat; he is long and fit! We were feeding him 4 ounces of Similac with Iron every 3 hours (during the day) and when he would wake up at night (about twice a night). She acted like we were feeding him too much. We only fed him when he cried and nothing else would soothe him. After this horrible visit with this particular doctor (whom we refuse to go see again), we would wait and try feeding our crying baby as a last measure only to find that he was really hungry and that he just wanted to eat. It was very discouraging and difficult for us for a while. He has his two-month visit soon and I'm so afraid of what he'll weigh. Can you tell me what's normal in terms of weight at his age and how much he should be eating and the frequency. Right now he's up to about 6 ounces every 3-4 hours except at night, when he wakes up only once to eat. There are no guidelines, we just feed him until he seems satisfied. Is this wrong?

Thank you.

-SR

Dear SR: Four pounds is a huge amount of weight gain in 1 month for a newborn, but whether or not it is excessive depends on how many inches he grew. His current weight is in the 97th percentile. If his height is in the same percentile, you're simply dealing with a child who is growing rapidly. I've seen skinny babies wolf down 8 ounce feedings, and I've seen chubby little babies eating only 4 ounces at a feeding, so it's difficult to give exact guidelines. Parents need to avoid feeding infants for every cry because it teaches children to use food to deal with any distress, but when an infant is hungry, he should be fed. The idea of a mother sitting on the edge of her bed watching a clock while her baby screams to be fed is absurd. After most infants settle in, they will find a reasonable amount to consume for normal growth. Some infants tend to gain excessively, probably based on a genetic predisposition. Many of these babies slim down as they get older, but if you believe that the number of fat cells a person has will affect his weight later in life, it seems wise to avoid getting infants too fat. If a baby continues to gain weight in excess of height, which can best be judged by looking at his growth chart for height and weight, then the simplest thing to do is to add some water to each bottle.

I do not believe you are doing anything wrong. If your baby's weight gain is truly excessive, your doctor can help you work out a feeding schedule and an appropriate formula dilution without accusing you of being a bad parent.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

If your questions haven't been answered here, perhaps you would like to
ask Dr. Warren a NEW question?!?

Return to Ask Dr. Warren Home Page Contact Dr. Warren