Ask Dr. Warren ~ The Questions & Their Answers


4 January 1999

  1. Causes of Diarrhea
  2. Evaluating Claims of Health Benefits for Unproven Therapies
  3. Caring for Children With Eating Disorders
  4. Polycythemia
  5. Infrequent Bowel Movements
  6. Infant Breathing Rate
  7. Is It Epilepsy?
  8. Don't Ignore Pain
  9. Disclaimer

Disclaimer

Dear Readers:
Dr. Warren hopes to help all who ask his advice and to enlighten all who read Ask Dr. Warren. For your own well being please keep in mind that advice you read here may not apply exactly to your own situation, and that if you are sick, no information on the web can take the place of a hands on examination by your physician who knows you and cares about you.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Causes of Diarrhea

Dr. Warren: My 19 month old neice has had diarrhea for about 6 months now. She was taken off of milk but the problem still exists. Her white blood cell count is normal and a stool sample showed no viral or bacterial infections.

What other causes are there for diarrhea besides milk allergy or infection? Thanks for any advice.

-DD

Dear DD: Six months is a long time to have diarrhea. Let's first be sure we're talking about the same thing. If your child has 1 or 2 loose bowel movements per day, is gaining weight well, has a good appetite, and does not appear to be having abdominal pains, I would not call that diarrhea, and I wouldn't pursue the matter. If your daughter is having frequent, watery bowel movements, or muscousy movements associated with cramping, decreased appetite, or poor weight gain, she needs further evaluation.

Parasites may also cause diarrhea. If tests for viral and bacterial infections have been negative, your daughter should be tested for parasites.

Usually when milk intolerance causes diarrhea it is not allergy, but rather lactose intolerance (an inability to digest lactose). Intolerance of other sugars may cause the same problem. One of the most common causes of diarrhea in children is excess consumption of fruit juice.

Malabsorption of other nutrients, irritable colon, and inflammatory bowel disease are also possible causes of diarrhea. Evaluation and treatment for less common causes of diarrhea might best be undertaken with a pediatric gastroenterologist.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Evaluating Claims of Health Benefits for Unproven Therapies

Dear Dr. Warren: What do you know about the Manchurian Mushroom and Kombucha Tea? When I did a search on the Internet for Kombucha, I found some information. My parents have made this tea. They got a culture from a friend. I was concerned and wanted to get an expert opinion. I sent a message to Dr. Weil on his website. It will probably be a while before I get a reply. Thanks for you quick reply.

-Chris

Dear Chris: As a physician, I tend to be careful about suggesting any treatment whose claims have not been proven scientifically. Most of the information about Kombucha on the Net is in the form of testimonials. These anecdotes of health benefits people have had from using Kombucha do not constitute proof. On the other hand, scientific proof requires a large sample and a statistical analysis which could prove something to be ineffective even if it truly helps a small number of people. To look at those possiblities one must at least have an explanation of what ingredients make a potion work, and how it works.

The other side of the coin is that even if something can't be proven to work, will using it cause any harm? Remember that if sick people die while taking Kombucha, that doesn't prove that Kombucha contributed to their death. Again, a cause and effect mechanism must be found, or a large sample must show statistically that a particular ill effect is seen more in Kombucha drinkers than those who abstain.

My personal bias is to be cautious about taking anything that may be questionable. If you haven't looked at the following two articles, you should.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Caring for Children With Eating Disorders

Doctor: My 2 granddaughters will be coming to live with me and I have been told that they have a number of problems. They are 7 & 8 years old and supposedly both have the eating disorders anorexia & bulemia. Do you have any suggestions regarding helping them and have you ever heard of children this young with these disorders. The older one was hospitalized in August because she vomited so much that she had a siezure. They ran lots of tests in the hospital and said that they found nothing physical.

Thank you,
-Ellen

Dear Ellen: Seven and eight years old is very young to have eating disorders. The fact that both granddaughters have it adds to the concern. You don't say what is going on in their lives that they are coming to live with you, but you should be aware that the treatment of eating disorders involves treating the psychological aspects of it as well as the physical aspects of it. Children with ongoing eating disorders require the attention of a physician and psychologist experienced in dealing with eating disorders.

I would suggest that you schedule a conference with the doctors who cared for your granddaughters to be sure that you are familiar with their treatment program. If their living with you will take them away from those doctors, you should ask for a referral to physicians in your area who will be able to continue their care and advise you on their management. If the reasons for their move to you include troubles at home or any major change in their lives, you might also want to plan for professional psychological counseling. There are many excellent resources available to children with eating disorders. You would probably be wise to not go it alone until you are sure you have things under control.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Polycythemia

Dear Dr. Warren: My step-father is a white 47 year old male. He has suffered from very high blood pressure for several years. It has been controlled with drugs up until the last several months. He went to the Dr last week where he took a blood test. Today the test came back as saying he had Polycythemia. I know that this means an increase in the concentration of red blood cells in the blood. What we would like to know is there any complications from this and also could he donate blood to bone marrow patients as they have a low red blood cell count?.

Any advice would be appreciated.
Thankyou.

-Nikki

Dear Nikki: If the red cell count becomes very high it makes the blood thicker, and that increases the risk of stroke. Your stepfather can control the polycythemia by having blood removed regularly. If he has no blood borne diseases like Hepatitis B, he can certainly donate blood regularly to a blood bank since there is always a need for blood. He will be saving lives while he helps himself.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Infrequent Bowel Movements

Dear Dr. Warren: I have a baby boy who is going to be 4 months old on Nov 6th. He is very healthy and progressing very well in all of his skills, but I have one concern: He does not have bowel movements regularly. It is usually 4 to 5 days between bm's. I have had two pediatrician's tell me it's ok. One said to give him prune juice. The other said to put syrup in his milk. The prune juice seems to work well but the syrup gives him gas to bad, so I guess my question is: Is this normal or could there be something wrong? I have tried a little bit of cereal out on him and when he eats that it seems to help him have bm's but it also gives him gas. I guess i'm a confused new mom can you help?

Thank You

-Jenny

Dear Jenny: Bowel habits vary from child to child. Diet may play a role, but some children tend to be constipated and others don't. Some nursing babies may go as infrequently as every 4 to 5 days and it's perfectly normal. If your baby's bowel movements are not hard and he is not uncomfortable, it is okay for him to move his bowels every 4 to 5 days. If the stools are hard, then it's okay to give him the prune juice regularly if it helps.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Infant Breathing Rate

Dear Dr. Warren: Hello.

My 11 month old baby has this breathing condition; he has been diagnosed with a light bronchial inflammation ( letīs say bronchitis ), and the Doctor has prescribed among other things antiobitic and the use of a nebulizer. The question is, I donīt know if its normal that my son has a breathing rate of 50-55 per minute, and if this condition can or can not lead to another serious illness, considering that the baby hasnīt had fever or other condition beside that I described.

-E

Dear E: A breathing rate of about 40 per minute at rest would be normal for an infant, so 50 to 55 is a bit fast, but not alarming. If the baby is active, his respiratory rate will go up, so you must be sure you are counting his breathing when he is quiet and not excited.

A nebulizer can be very useful for treating acute symptoms of wheezing associated with asthma and bronchiolitis. There are also medications which can be given by nebulizer for long-term management of asthma. If your child has persistent or recurrent wheezing, it can be managed with medication, but requires close medical follow up to determine the best treatment.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Is It Epilepsy?

Dear Dr. Warren: I have a two year old daughter with asthma since she was born. About three months ago she started having seizures mostly when she is asleep. The doctors did an mri and it was normal. They also did a eeg showed spiking on left frontal part of her brain. They put her on tegretol and now she had another one. They uped her dose to 3ml 3x a day. My husband is military and we are stationed in England. We have limited medical care. We are worried that we aren't getting any clear answers. Is she epileptic or just a seizure disorder? Do you think there is more they could do for her? Any help you could give would be helpful. Thank you.

-TE

Dear TE: Epilepsy is a term that has largely gone out of use because of the great deal of stigma associated with it. There is no difference between a diagnosis of epilepsy and a seizure disorder. They are both the same thing.

Having a normal MRI tells you that the structure of your daughter's brain is normal. The abnormal EEG associated with seizures confirms that your daughter has a seizure disorder. Evaluation for the causes of seizures also includes some metabolic tests such as measuring the blood concentration of calcium, magnesium, sodium, and glucose at or near the time of the seizure. If clinically indicated, your neurologist might also want to check for lead intoxication and rare metabolic disorders by checking a blood lead level and obtaining urine for mucopolysaccharides, amino acids, and toxicology.

Management of seizures may require close monitoring of anticonvulsant levels and trials of different medications until one is found that controls the seizures well.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

Don't Ignore Pain

Hi Doctor: Please be kind enough to help me. I am 21 years old man. I am engaged in martial arts so I do some exercises 3 times a week. My problem is on my right leg the front part of the thigh and back part of the shin gives a continues pain after I do my excersies for about 3 or 4 days. Please give me the treatment. Awaiting for your reply.

Yours
Patient
Rushdi

Dear Rushdi: Pain is often a signal from the body that something is wrong. Three to four days of pain after an activity cries out for a change in your activities. Perhaps you have strained a muscle. If you have injured yourself and continue to ignore the pain your injury may get worse. You need evaluation by an orthopedist to determine what is causing your pain. When your condition has improved after you have started on appropriate therapy for your problem you will probably be able to resume your activities, but while you are having a great deal of pain, I have to recommend that you listen to your body.

Sincerely,
Dr. Warren

Top of Page

If your questions haven't been answered here, perhaps you would like to
ask Dr. Warren a NEW question?!?

Return to Ask Dr. Warren Home Page Contact Dr. Warren